Starship HLS

The lunar version of Starship, chosen by NASA to land astronauts; it must be refilled in orbit before every trip.

Status
In development
Height
52 m
171 ft
Built by
SpaceX

How SpaceX won NASA’s first Moon lander, and what it must still prove

Drawn from 19 sources: NASA (11), NASA Office of Inspector General (2), NASA Marshall Space Flight Center (2), U.S. Government Accountability Office and 3 others. About 9 minutes. Checked November 9, 2026.

The vehicle that carries Artemis astronauts the last stretch to the Moon is the Human Landing System. It must take two crew members from lunar orbit down to the surface, serve as their living quarters while they live and work there, and lift them back to orbit. NASA has bought two: SpaceX’s Starship lander and Blue Origin’s Blue Moon.1

NASA does not own either one. It buys the landers as a service, under firm-fixed-price contracts that pay the companies only after NASA determines that a milestone has been met, and the companies design, build and own the vehicles.1 The first and largest of these contracts went to a version of SpaceX’s Starship that never returns to Earth and must be refilled in Earth orbit before every trip. What the two lander contracts cost together, and how buying a service compares with the way NASA buys SLS and Orion, is part of the Artemis plan; this story follows the SpaceX lander.

One lander instead of two: the April 2021 selection

Artist’s concept: a tall white Starship stands on four landing legs on gray lunar ground, with a band of windows near its nose and the small blue Earth above the horizon in a black sky.
An artist’s concept of the Starship lander on the Moon, with Earth above the horizon.SpaceX artist concept, via NASA

In March 2019 NASA committed to landing humans at the Moon’s South Pole by 2024 instead of 2028, as it had planned.2 In September of that year it asked industry to propose an initial lander. Five companies did, and on April 30, 2020, NASA announced firm-fixed-price contracts with three of them to begin design, worth $967 million in all for a 10-month base period.17 According to the inspector general, Blue Origin received more than $480 million, Dynetics nearly $240 million and SpaceX nearly $135 million for that base period.1

The plan was to carry at least two of the three into full development, so that competition would hold down cost. Then Congress gave the program $850 million for fiscal year 2021, against the $3.4 billion NASA had requested, and NASA could afford only one.2,1 On April 16, 2021, it chose SpaceX, under a firm-fixed-price, milestone-based award worth $2.89 billion, known as Option A. The mission it described was this: SLS would launch four astronauts in Orion to lunar orbit, where two would transfer to the SpaceX lander for the final leg to the surface. After about a week exploring, they would board the lander for the short trip back to orbit, return to Orion and their colleagues, and head home. NASA noted that the design leaned on SpaceX’s tested Raptor engines and the flight heritage of Falcon and Dragon, and offered a spacious cabin and two airlocks for moonwalks.3 The award also required an uncrewed demonstration landing before the crewed one.1

The losing bidders challenged the award at the Government Accountability Office, Blue Origin then sued in federal court, and each challenge stopped work on the contract.4

The 2021 protests

  1. April 26, 2021

    Protests filed at GAO4

    Blue Origin Federation and Dynetics challenge the selection; NASA tells SpaceX to suspend work.

  2. July 30, 2021

    GAO denies both protests4

    NASA awards the Option A contract to SpaceX.

  3. August 13, 2021

    Blue Origin sues4

    A bid protest in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims; NASA and SpaceX agree to stop work until as late as November 8 to allow an accelerated schedule.

  4. November 4, 2021

    Court denies the protest4

    The court upholds NASA’s selection, and work resumes.

The protests cost six months: in December 2021 the date for delivering the lander moved from December 2024 to June 2025.1

A second contract option, a second lander, and fixed prices that held

In March 2022 NASA said it would add work to the SpaceX contract, and on November 15, 2022, it awarded Option B, a modification worth about $1.15 billion. Under it SpaceX is to develop a lander that meets NASA’s requirements for “sustaining” missions after the first landing, including docking with the Gateway station, carrying four crew members and landing more mass on the Moon, and to demonstrate it on Artemis IV.5,4 Counting every option and order, NASA’s inspector general put the original potential value of SpaceX’s contract at about $4.3 billion. To keep a second lander available, NASA ran a separate competition in 2022, which Blue Origin won in May 2023.1

The fixed prices have largely held. By December 2025 SpaceX’s potential contract value had grown about 6 percent, partly because of government-driven changes such as new requirements for how the lander connects with the spacesuits, which added $26.2 million in 2023.1 SpaceX said in October 2025 that it had been paid about $2.7 billion for 49 completed milestones, which it said included showing how the lander’s docking, landing, life-support and thermal-control systems would work.15 How NASA traded SpaceX’s 2023 delay for an added ascent test instead of more money, and why a fixed price behaves differently from a cost-plus contract when a schedule slips, is part of the Artemis plan.

Refill, dock, descend: the lander’s mission step by step

SpaceX intends to use three configurations of Starship for Artemis: the lander, tankers and a storage depot.1 The model follows one landing mission from launch to the surface.

A Starship that never comes home

The lander stands about 171 feet tall and launches on SpaceX’s Super Heavy booster, without a crew. It is built around what a lunar mission needs: a crew compartment, docking hardware, solar arrays and landing legs.1,6 Before each landing SpaceX will fill a depot in low Earth orbit from more than ten tankers, the campaign Refilling in orbit follows; the lander then docks with the depot and refuels.1,19

Orion docks in Earth orbit, and Starship pushes it to the Moon

Under the plan NASA described in October 2026, the fueled lander waits for the crew in Earth orbit, not lunar orbit: Orion and its crew dock with it there, and Starship’s engines push the two to the Moon, for which NASA is modifying Orion. SpaceX’s docking system is based on the one flown on Dragon and was qualified in tests of more than 200 docking scenarios.1,6,8,19

A braking burn and a landing on legs

After leaving low lunar orbit, the lander slows with a braking burn of its Raptor engines before the final descent. In August 2023 SpaceX started one of the vacuum engines in extreme cold to show it could meet the demands of a descent. Near the ground the exhaust throws up dust and rock, and NASA’s models of that still rest largely on Apollo.8,6,1

An elevator from 115 feet up

The crew compartment sits near the top. To reach the surface, astronauts leave through an airlock deck and ride an elevator basket down a vertical rail. The elevator sits about 115 feet above the ground, taller than the Statue of Liberty from heel to head, and also carries equipment and samples.1,7,6

A cabin for a week on the Moon

Two astronauts would stay about six and a half days and walk on the surface in Axiom Space suits. SpaceX built a full-scale cabin mockup to test life support and thermal control with four people working inside, and in 2026 it was building a flight-like cabin at Starbase. When the stay ends, the lander lifts off, climbs back to orbit and docks with Orion.1,6,13

Milestones met, but the ship-to-ship transfer has not flown

By NASA’s count, SpaceX had completed more than two dozen lander-specific milestones by 2024, designing and testing hardware for power generation, communications, guidance and navigation, propulsion, life support and protection from the space environment. In November 2023 the program passed Key Decision Point C, NASA’s approval to proceed to final design and fabrication. In February 2024 SpaceX showed at a design review for the integrated lander that the design met NASA’s requirements within acceptable risk and schedule margins.6

Astronauts have worked in the hardware. In late 2023 NASA astronauts Nicole Mann and Doug Wheelock tested a subscale mockup of the elevator, built at SpaceX in Hawthorne, California, and reported on its controls, gate latches, ramps, cargo space and ride along the rail.7 In 2024 Wheelock and Axiom Space astronaut Peggy Whitson put on pressurized suits and worked in a full-scale mockup of the airlock, hatch and elevator basket, checking handrails, clearances and whether controls could be worked in spacesuit gloves.6

Most of the visible progress has come from Starship’s own test flights, which serve SpaceX’s other plans as well as the lander. On the third flight, in March 2024, SpaceX moved thousands of pounds of super-cold liquid oxygen between a header tank and a main tank inside one ship, under a NASA Tipping Point award.14,6 That was a precursor to the step the lander cannot do without, a long-duration transfer of propellant between two ships in low Earth orbit.

That transfer was to use the third version of Starship. After SpaceX moved from the first version to the second, three of the next five flights ended with the loss of the ship, and each mishap cost one to three months.1 The third version first flew in May 2026, and on September 28, 2026, a Starship reached orbit for the first time.1,10,16

What the inspector general flagged: tipping, the elevator, manual control and testing

Of all the systems needed for an Artemis mission, NASA’s inspector general wrote in March 2026, the lander carries the highest probability of crew loss. NASA’s own estimates for Starship on the first two landings met the agency’s thresholds, no more than a 1-in-40 chance of losing the crew during lunar operations and 1-in-30 over the whole mission, but the lander was still the largest contributor to that risk, driven by possible failures in avionics, main engines, propulsion, landing legs and electrical power.1

How high the crew rides: lander heights in feet1

Apollo lunar module23 ftBlue Moon crew lander52 ftStarship elevator, top115 ftStarship lander171 ft
On the Apollo lunar module and on Blue Moon the crew climbs stairs about 6 feet off the ground; on Starship they ride an elevator from about 115 feet.
Show the numbers
LanderHeight above the surface
Apollo lunar module23 ft
Blue Moon crew lander52 ft
Starship elevator, top115 ft
Starship lander171 ft

Tipping over. NASA chose the South Pole for its science, but the terrain there is rugged, strewn with rocks more than 65 feet across, cut by deep craters and sloped as steeply as 20 degrees. Given Starship’s height of 171 feet, about a 14-story building, there is a risk that its momentum will continue after landing and tip it over. NASA set a limit of 8 degrees of tilt for both landers to support the crew’s work after landing; beyond it, equipment such as the hatch may not work.1

Two suited astronauts stand in a white mesh elevator basket hanging from a steel frame, in a test facility.
The full-scale elevator basket mockup, 2024.SpaceX, released by NASA

The elevator. Starship’s elevator sits just below the crew compartment, about 115 feet above the ground, and there is currently no other way for the crew to get back into the vehicle from the surface if it fails. NASA requires that the lander tolerate at least a single failure without catastrophe. SpaceX is building the elevator with redundant mechanisms, but NASA tracks it as a top risk and is working with SpaceX on another way in should it jam while the crew is outside.1

Manual control. NASA’s rules for rating a vehicle safe for crew require that astronauts be able to take manual control in every phase of flight, especially descent and landing. On every one of Apollo’s seven planned crewed landings, astronauts used the backup manual control, and in June 2024 the crew of Boeing’s Starliner held their position near the space station by hand after thrusters failed. NASA and SpaceX disagree on whether SpaceX’s proposed approach to landing meets the intent of the requirement, and NASA’s tracking of the risk showed a worsening trend. If no solution is agreed before the critical design review, the inspector general warned, automation could be locked in as the only way to land.1

Testing. The uncrewed demonstration landing must show a precision landing, two hours of reports on the lander’s health and an ascent from the surface, but NASA did not require it to carry the life-support system, the airlocks or the elevator. The elevator will therefore not be tried on a tilted lunar surface before a crew rides it.1

Two years behind, and no longer assigned the first landing

The inspector general found SpaceX’s Artemis III lander at least two years behind its 2021 schedule. The critical design review slipped to August 2026, and the uncrewed demonstration landing was expected to slip to the end of 2026, leaving about six months before the crewed one.1 The date of the first crewed landing has moved four times since it was set in 2019.2,11,12 How SpaceX’s delivery date moved, its warning in the fall of 2025 that it might miss June 2027, and NASA’s request to both companies for faster plans are part of the Artemis plan.

How SpaceX’s lander delivery and its test landing slipped1

202120222023202420252026202720282029NowDelivery of SpaceX’s first crew landerSaid Apr 2021Dec. 2024Said Dec 2021June 2025Said in 2023Sept. 2026Uncrewed demonstration landingSaid Mar 2026Late 2026Said Oct 2026Late 2027

2021202420262029

Delivery of SpaceX’s first crew lander

  1. Said Apr 2021Dec. 2024
  2. Said Dec 2021June 2025
  3. Said in 2023Sept. 2026

Uncrewed demonstration landing

  1. Said Mar 2026Late 2026
  2. Said Oct 2026Late 2027
Each bar runs from the date a plan was announced to the date it promised. The lander’s delivery moved six months after the 2021 protests and 15 months at SpaceX’s request in 2023. The uncrewed test landing, expected by the end of 2026 in the inspector general’s March report, stood at the end of 2027 in NASA’s October schedule.

At the end of October 2025 SpaceX said it had shared “a simplified mission architecture and concept of operations” that it believed would mean a faster return to the Moon and better crew safety.15 NASA had meanwhile restructured Artemis. On February 27, 2026, it made Artemis III a crewed test in low Earth orbit in 2027 and moved the first landing to Artemis IV in 2028.12 On October 23 it said it had updated both lander contracts earlier in the year: Starship had been assigned to Artemis III and IV, and now neither company is assigned to a specific landing. Based on lander readiness, NASA will choose which one lands first in 2028, and a second crewed landing opportunity will follow.19

For the Artemis III test SpaceX will fly a Starship Version 3 with a docking system added to its nose. Orion will dock with it nose to nose, and the Starship will control the joined spacecraft while teams measure how they move together. Astronauts will not go inside.9

The schedule that NASA’s lander program manager, Steve Creech, presented in October puts SpaceX’s remaining steps in order.18

What SpaceX still has to fly

  1. End of 2026

    A ship caught, a flight from Florida18

    SpaceX is to catch a returning Starship for the first time and launch one from Florida.

  2. First quarter of 2027

    Propellant moved between two ships18

    The first transfer of propellant between two Starships in orbit.

  3. Third quarter of 2027

    The Artemis III docking test, and the first tanker18

    Orion docks with a Starship in Earth orbit, and the first tanker for the uncrewed demonstration flies.

  4. Late 2027

    The demonstration lander19

    The uncrewed lander launches; the flight is also to demonstrate propellant aggregation.

The demonstration landing, and every crewed Starship landing after it, still depends on that first transfer between two Starships.18

Sources

The text above is drawn from these 19 sources. Government works are adapted closely; company and press material is summarized. Numbers in the text point here. Last checked November 9, 2026.

Show all 19 sourcesShow fewer
  1. 1
    NASA’s Management of the Human Landing System Contracts (IG-26-004)NASA Office of Inspector General, March 10, 2026
  2. 2
    NASA’s Management of the Artemis Missions (IG-22-003)NASA Office of Inspector General, November 15, 2021
  3. 3
  4. 4
    NextSTEP-2 H: Human Landing System (procurement record)NASA, 2019–2022; accessed October 1, 2026
  5. 5
  6. 6
    NASA’s Human Landing System Program: Progress Toward Artemis III and Beyond (IAC-24.B3.1.11)Lisa Watson-Morgan, Kent Chojnacki, Rene Ortega, Thomas K. Percy, John Crisler, NASA Marshall Space Flight Center, October 2024
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
    NASA: Assessments of Major Projects (GAO-26-108556)U.S. Government Accountability Office, July 23, 2026
  11. 11
  12. 12
  13. 13
    Returning to the Moon (Ignition presentation)NASA Exploration Systems Development Mission Directorate, March 2026
  14. 14
  15. 15
    SpaceX, Blue Origin share new lunar landing profilesJack Daleo, FLYING, via Astronomy, November 4, 2025
  16. 16
  17. 17
  18. 18
  19. 19

Continue

Next in Return to the Moon

Blue Moon: NASA’s second crew lander and the cargo lander that goes first

In May 2023 NASA awarded Blue Origin a $3.4 billion contract for a second way to land astronauts. The first of the smaller robotic Mark 1 landers is built and tested, and is waiting for New Glenn to fly again.